11 Best Whiskeys for Manhattan

When crafting a Manhattan, choosing the right whiskey brand can make a world of difference. Here are some well-known whiskey brands commonly used in Manhattans, each with its unique characteristics and offerings:

Basil Hayden's Toast is a distinctive bourbon whiskey that boasts a unique flavor profile. Crafted by the renowned Kentucky-based distillery, this expression is known for its intriguing combination of rich caramel and vanilla notes, complemented by a subtle hint of dark fruit and toasted oak. What sets Basil Hayden Toast apart is its extra layer of complexity achieved through a unique toasted barrel finishing process. The result is a well-balanced and flavorful whiskey that's perfect for those looking to explore the world of bourbon with a touch of sophistication and innovation.

Legent Bourbon is a collaborative masterpiece between two whiskey giants, blending the expertise of American bourbon and Japanese whisky craftsmanship. This exceptional bourbon offers a harmonious fusion of rich, full-bodied bourbon flavors, with a nuanced Japanese influence that adds layers of complexity. It presents a well-balanced palate of caramel, dried fruit, and vanilla, coupled with subtle hints of spice and oak. Legent Bourbon is known for its smooth and approachable character, making it a fantastic choice for both bourbon enthusiasts and those seeking a unique, refined whiskey experience that bridges the traditions of two distinct whiskey-making cultures.

Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey is a celebrated and meticulously crafted bourbon that hails from the heart of Kentucky's bourbon country. Distilled at the historic Woodford Reserve Distillery, it is known for its exceptional quality and attention to detail. This bourbon offers a rich and complex flavor profile with prominent notes of dried fruit, vanilla, and toasted oak, along with a subtle hint of spices. Its well-balanced and smooth character has made it a favorite among bourbon connoisseurs and cocktail enthusiasts alike. Woodford Reserve embodies the quintessential qualities of a Kentucky straight bourbon, delivering a timeless and authentic taste that pays homage to the region's proud bourbon-making heritage.

Rittenhouse Straight Rye Whisky is a cherished American rye whiskey renowned for its bold and robust flavor profile. Produced in the heart of Pennsylvania, it epitomizes the classic rye whiskey tradition. This whisky is characterized by its spicy and peppery notes, along with a distinct sweetness that hints at caramel and toffee. With a higher rye content than most, Rittenhouse delivers a full-bodied and satisfying experience for whiskey enthusiasts. Whether enjoyed neat, in cocktails, or as a sipping whiskey, Rittenhouse Straight Rye Whisky embodies the essence of American rye whiskey, offering a taste of history and tradition in every sip.

Bulleit Bourbon 10 Year Old is a premium offering from the Bulleit Distilling Co., known for its commitment to producing high-quality bourbon. This particular expression represents a step up in age, resulting in a more mature and complex flavor profile. It is distinguished by its rich and deep caramel notes, accompanied by a harmonious blend of vanilla and spice. The 10 years of aging in charred oak barrels impart a smooth and refined character to this bourbon, making it an excellent choice for sipping neat or crafting sophisticated cocktails. Bulleit Bourbon 10 Year Old showcases the brand's dedication to quality and craftsmanship, appealing to bourbon enthusiasts looking for a well-aged and flavorful whiskey experience.

Willett Family Estate Cask Strength 4-Year Rye Whiskey is a highly sought-after and limited-release rye whiskey that hails from the esteemed Willett Distillery in Kentucky. This expression is celebrated for its bold and intense flavor profile and its rarity. It offers a delightful interplay of spicy rye grains, complemented by caramel, vanilla, and oak notes. Being cask strength, it boasts a high alcohol content, which contributes to its robust character and complexity. Each bottle is a testament to the Willett family's commitment to crafting exceptional spirits. This 4-year rye whiskey is a true gem for whiskey aficionados, providing a memorable and intense sipping experience that reflects the rich tradition and expertise of the Willett Distillery.

Pikesville Rye is a classic and beloved American rye whiskey known for its historical significance and exceptional taste. Distilled in Maryland, it has a legacy that dates back to the 19th century. Pikesville Rye is characterized by its spicy and peppery rye grain flavors, balanced by sweet undertones of caramel and vanilla. It has a smooth and approachable character that appeals to both rye enthusiasts and those new to the category. This whiskey pays homage to the traditional Maryland rye style and offers a taste of the past while maintaining its relevance in today's whiskey landscape. Pikesville Rye is a testament to the enduring appeal of well-crafted, classic American rye whiskey.

Wilderness Trail Bourbon is a rising star in the world of American whiskey, produced by Wilderness Trail Distillery located in Kentucky. This bourbon is quickly gaining recognition for its exceptional quality and craftsmanship. It presents a well-balanced flavor profile with prominent notes of caramel, vanilla, and baking spices, offering a deliciously smooth and approachable taste. What sets Wilderness Trail Bourbon apart is its dedication to using non-GMO ingredients, sweet mash fermentation, and a slow, small-batch distillation process, resulting in a whiskey that's both flavorful and unique. Whether enjoyed neat or in cocktails, Wilderness Trail Bourbon showcases a commitment to producing high-quality bourbon that appeals to both connoisseurs and those exploring the world of whiskey.

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked Bourbon is a standout offering from the renowned Woodford Reserve Distillery, known for its innovative approach to bourbon-making. This expression undergoes a unique aging process where it is first matured in new charred oak barrels and then transferred to a second, deeply toasted, and lightly charred barrel. This double-barreling technique imparts a rich and complex flavor profile with pronounced notes of caramel, toffee, and dark chocolate, along with subtle hints of vanilla and spices. It offers a velvety, full-bodied mouthfeel and a long, lingering finish. Woodford Reserve Double Oaked Bourbon is an excellent choice for those seeking a bourbon with a luxurious and layered taste, making it a standout in the world of whiskey.

Maker's Mark 46 Bourbon is a delightful variation of the classic Maker's Mark Bourbon, known for its distinctive character and handcrafted approach. Maker's Mark 46 undergoes a unique aging process where French oak staves are inserted into the barrels, enhancing the whiskey's flavor and complexity. This results in a bourbon with a rich and sophisticated taste profile, featuring notes of caramel, vanilla, and baking spices, with a subtle undertone of toasted oak and dark fruits. The addition of French oak imparts a touch of elegance to the bourbon, making Maker's Mark 46 a favorite among those who appreciate a well-balanced and flavorful whiskey with a slight twist on tradition. It's an excellent choice for sipping neat or crafting exceptional cocktails, showcasing Maker's Mark's commitment to quality and innovation in bourbon production.

Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon is a beloved and revered bourbon in the world of American whiskey. Named after the Reverend Elijah Craig, who is often credited with the invention of bourbon, this small batch expression embodies the rich heritage and craftsmanship of bourbon-making. It is characterized by its robust flavor profile, featuring notes of caramel, toffee, and vanilla, with a pleasant hint of spice and oak. The small batch production process ensures consistency and a depth of flavor that appeals to both connoisseurs and newcomers to bourbon. Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon is celebrated for its smooth and approachable nature, making it an ideal choice for sipping neat or enjoying in classic bourbon cocktails. It stands as a testament to the enduring legacy of bourbon and the dedication of its distillers to produce exceptional spirits.

When it comes to selecting whiskey for your Manhattan, you have several options. Each type of whiskey brings its own unique character to the cocktail. Let's explore the three main types:

Bourbon Characteristics

Bourbon is a type of whiskey primarily made from corn, giving it a sweet and full-bodied flavor. It often features notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak.

Why bourbon is a popular choice for Manhattans

Bourbon's sweetness and richness can complement the sweetness of vermouth in a Manhattan, creating a well-balanced and flavorful cocktail.

Rye Characteristics

Rye whiskey is made predominantly from rye grain, resulting in a spicier and more assertive flavor profile with notes of pepper and herbs.

Why rye whiskey is historically associated with Manhattans

Rye whiskey was the original choice for Manhattans, and its bold flavor profile provides a robust backbone to the cocktail.

Flavor Profile

Consider the flavor profile of different whiskeys and how they can impact the overall taste of your Manhattan. Bourbon offers sweetness, rye provides spiciness, and blended whiskey offers balance.

Budget

Your budget can influence your whiskey choices. Fortunately, there are options available at various price points, so you can craft a Manhattan that suits your financial preferences.

Personal Preference

Personal taste plays a significant role in selecting the right whiskey. Experiment and find a whiskey that resonates with your palate to create a Manhattan you love.

In conclusion, selecting the best whiskey for your Manhattan can elevate this classic cocktail to new heights. Whether you choose bourbon, rye, or blended whiskey, understanding the characteristics of each type and considering your personal preferences are key. Don't be afraid to experiment and create a Manhattan that suits your taste buds. Cheers to the art of crafting the perfect Manhattan!