The Best Whiskeys for Hot Toddy: A Connoisseur's Guide

Peng Lin

21 November, 2023

As winter winds whisper and nights lengthen, find comfort in a hot toddy's warmth. This guide explores whiskies that elevate this classic drink, from the peaty depths of Scotch to the smooth sweetness of Bourbon. Whether you're a seasoned enthusiast or new to whiskey, discover insights to turn your toddy into a luxurious experience. Join us on a flavorful journey to find the perfect whiskey for your next cozy moment.

Table Of Contents:

  1. What Is a Hot Toddy?
  2. Which Whiskey Is Good for a Sore Throat?
  3. What Kind of Whiskey Do You Use for a Hot Toddy?
  4. Top 17 Hot Toddy Whiskey Recommendations
  5. Larceny
  6. Four Roses Yellow Label
  7. Maker’s Mark
  8. Angel’s Envy Finished Rye
  9. Woodford Reserve
  10. Buffalo Trace
  11. Wild Turkey 101
  12. GlenDronach 12
  13. Dewar’s White Label
  14. Glenmorangie The Original
  15. The Famous Grouse
  16. Monkey Shoulder
  17. Ardbeg 10
  18. Cutty Sark Prohibition Edition
  19. Aberlour 12 Double Cask
  20. The Glenlivet 12
  21. Bruichladdich The Classic Laddie
  22. Conclusion

What Is a Hot Toddy?

A hot toddy is a classic, comforting drink traditionally made with whiskey, hot water, honey, lemon, and spices like cloves and cinnamon. Believed to have originated in Scotland or India, this soothing beverage has evolved over time, with variations now incorporating different types of whiskey, tea, or apple cider. While it's renowned for its warmth and supposed health benefits during cold seasons, a hot toddy's appeal lies in its simplicity and the perfect balance of sweet, spicy, and citrus flavors, making it a timeless choice for winter evenings or as a remedy for the common cold.

Which Whiskey Is Good for a Sore Throat?

When choosing a whiskey to soothe a sore throat, opt for smoother, lower-proof options. Irish whiskey, known for its gentle, fruity notes, or wheated bourbons like Maker's Mark, which are milder and sweeter, are ideal choices. These types of whiskey, combined with honey's natural soothing properties and lemon's refreshing tang, create a hot toddy that's both comforting and kind to a sore throat. However, it's important to enjoy it in moderation, as excessive alcohol can lead to dehydration.

What Kind of Whiskey Do You Use for a Hot Toddy?

Selecting the right whiskey for a hot toddy depends on the flavor profile you prefer:

  • Irish Whiskey: Known for its smoothness and light sweetness, brands like Jameson and Bushmills blend well without overpowering the other ingredients.
  • Bourbon: With its rich, vanilla, and caramel notes, bourbon like Maker's Mark or Woodford Reserve adds depth and complements the honey and lemon in the toddy.
  • Scotch Whisky: Offers a smoky or floral note, depending on the variety. Peated Scotch like Laphroaig adds smokiness, while something like Glenfiddich is smoother.
  • Rye Whiskey: Spicier and more robust, rye whiskeys such as Bulleit Rye enhance the drink's spice profile.

Each type of whiskey brings its unique character to a hot toddy, allowing for a range of flavor experiences based on your preference.

Top 17 Hot Toddy Whiskey Recommendations

Finding the perfect whiskey for your hot toddy can elevate this classic drink to new heights. Here, we've curated a selection of whiskeys that offer diverse flavors and characteristics, each bringing its unique touch to your hot toddy experience.


Larceny offers a smooth, wheated bourbon profile with a slightly sweet and buttery taste. Ideal for those who prefer a gentler, caramel-laden flavor in their hot toddy.

Four Roses Yellow Label

This bourbon stands out with its floral aroma and balanced, mellow flavor. Four Roses Yellow Label is perfect for a hot toddy that's smooth with a hint of spice.

Maker’s Mark

Known for its consistent quality, Maker's Mark has a sweet, rich flavor with notes of vanilla and caramel. Its smoothness makes it a crowd-pleaser in hot toddies.

Angel’s Envy Finished Rye

Angel's Envy Finished Rye is unique for its finishing in rum casks, offering a spicy yet sweet profile. It adds an intriguing complexity to a hot toddy.

Woodford Reserve

Woodford Reserve is a versatile bourbon with rich, full-bodied flavors and a smooth finish. It's excellent for a hot toddy that's robust and flavorful.

Buffalo Trace

Buffalo Trace is a reliable choice, known for its balanced and smooth profile with hints of spice and sweet oak. It adds a classic bourbon warmth to any hot toddy.

Wild Turkey 101

With its higher proof and bold flavors, Wild Turkey 101 brings a bit of kick to your hot toddy. It's perfect for those who enjoy a stronger whiskey presence.

GlenDronach 12

GlenDronach 12 is like a warm, fruity hug. Its sherried sophistication transforms your hot toddy into a drink that's both comforting and elegantly complex.

Dewar’s White Label

Dewar's White Label makes your hot toddy smooth and approachable, with a hint of heather honey sweetness. It's like a gentle, welcoming smile in a glass.

Glenmorangie The Original

Light, floral, and fruity – Glenmorangie The Original adds a delicate, almost whimsical touch to your hot toddy. It's a breath of fresh air on a crisp evening.

The Famous Grouse

The Famous Grouse is the reliable choice for a no-nonsense, classic hot toddy. Its smoothness and hint of smoke bring a sense of tradition and comfort.

Monkey Shoulder

Monkey Shoulder blends three single malts to create something that's effortlessly smooth and versatile. Its vanilla sweetness is like a gentle pat on the back.

Ardbeg 10

For the bold at heart, Ardbeg 10 adds a layer of smoky, peaty intensity. It's for when your hot toddy needs an edge, a strong character to stand out.

Cutty Sark Prohibition Edition

Cutty Sark Prohibition Edition is the daring choice, with its higher proof and bold flavors. It's your hot toddy's adventurous spirit, bringing a lively spark.

Aberlour 12 Double Cask

Aberlour 12 brings a rich complexity to your hot toddy, thanks to its double cask maturation. Each sip is like uncovering a new layer of sweet, spicy warmth.

The Glenlivet 12

The Glenlivet 12 is the epitome of elegance – smooth, fruity, and refined. It turns your hot toddy into an effortlessly classy affair.

Bruichladdich The Classic Laddie

For a unique twist, Bruichladdich The Classic Laddie offers a floral, complex profile. It's like a gentle, intriguing whisper in your hot toddy.


In the world of hot toddies, these whiskeys are more than just ingredients – they're the storytellers, each narrating a different tale. Whether you're in the mood for something soothing, bold, or sophisticated, there's a whiskey here that’s ready to match your mood and elevate your hot toddy experience.

Peng Lin

Peng Lin

Peng, a dynamic entrepreneur and founder of DKK, VIVA, and Liiton, has built customer-centric companies with three successful crowdfunding campaigns, skillfully developing unique products for style-conscious consumers while mastering product-market fit, and currently resides in Toronto with his family, continually pushing entrepreneurial boundaries.